
Date: Friday 5th February 2027
Time: 12 noon to 1pm
Place: MS Teams meeting
This paper is focused on the academic research community: ‘GenAI Literature Tools and Scholarly Diversity’ (Chandler et al., 2026). The research analyses and compares the results of traditional and GenAI literature searches using epistemic justice as a lens. It examines differences in how bias pokes its head into the search results. We hope to invite one of the authors to introduce the paper to the group, as Dr Kathy Chandler is my doctoral supervisor at Lancaster University.
This paper examines social imbalances around gender and geography and asks what kinds of knowledge is deemed credible; does GenAI redress or replicate the existing inequalities in the visibility of scholarly literature?
Chandler, K. M., Jordan, K., Al-Naabi, I., Tzanni, P., & Gately, L. (2026). ‘GenAI’ Literature Search Tools and Scholarly Diversity: An Algorithmic Ethnographical Analysis. Open Praxis, 18(2), 291–309. https://doi.org/10.55982/openpraxis.18.2.970
Potential discussion points:
The paper reveals that current AI search tools are better at providing more geographic diversity of research than traditional search tools. Is this surprising?
The paper argues that ranking search results by citation counts, namely how often a study is referenced in subsequent papers favours dominant research groups and reinforces existing inequalities. How persuasive do you find this argument?
The authors recommend training on how to use platforms and build critical skills to evaluate search results fairly and promote epistemic (knowledge) diversity. To what extent does this recommendation align with the values and priorities of universities in the current climate?
Get your Reading Group meeting invitation:
You must join the the UAL AI Network to receive your Reading Group invitation.
Author: Mark Robinson, Learning Technologist, LCF
Email: m.robinson@fashion.arts.ac.uk

Leave a Reply