1. The mediated self: Whose voice is it anyway?

Series introduction: The mediated self

The mediated self is a four-part series about how the media we use, and the stories we tell about them, shape who we think we are. We come to know ourselves partly through what we read, watch and write with, and now through AI. Change feels faster than ever, but the hopes and fears it stirs are much older. Part 1 asks whose voice is present in writing shaped by AI; part 2 looks at the panics that greet each new medium; part 3 looks at why AI arrived wrapped in stories of creations turning on their makers; and part 4 looks at how a different medium can be a way into learning rather than a way around it.

Part 1: Whose voice is it anyway?

When social media arrived, we all talked about how it connected us, from lost school friends to people who shared our hobbies and ideas. It took years, however, before we started to ask what it was doing to our sense of self. With generative AI that order has been reversed, with the anxiety coming first. Many of us were worried about what it would do to our writing, our thinking and our students before we had even typed a prompt.

I do have a confession. I am quite partial to TikTok and can find myself falling down a TikTok hole for far too long, despite knowing full well how it is designed to hold my attention. But knowing isn’t the same as being free of it, so I take seriously the current concern that AI could flatten not only our voices but potentially our selves.

A device showing the logos and names of popular social media apps.
Photo Pixabay via Pexels

In the early days of the internet, the self was something you authored: a homepage, a blog, a forum handle. These were built slowly, with thought and purpose, and largely on our own terms, at least for those with access. Social media turned the self into something more performed and amplified. The promise of voice was real, particularly for marginalised groups who had found mainstream channels closed to them. However, amplification works both ways, and algorithms began to shape what we saw and how we saw ourselves. Terms like “echo chamber” emerged to explain this, but as Jenny Davis (2020) argues in her work on affordances, platforms rarely force behaviour. They encourage, discourage and make some paths easier than others.

AI has introduced a third phase, in which some feel the self is becoming co-narrated. Earlier technologies reflected us back to ourselves, positively and negatively, or allowed us to be someone else. AI can seem as though it answers back: it offers words, proposes structures and sometimes finishes our sentences.

This feels like a real shift. Social media shaped what we saw; AI may shape what we say, and through that, who we are. Shannon Vallor (2024) describes AI as a mirror, but one that reflects an averaged past: the patterns of what has already been written, smoothed out by probability. If we write through this mirror without noticing, the risk of flattening is not imagined.

Much of this debate, like many around AI, is framed as a position to take, for or against, as if AI does all the work and we simply receive the results. I think this gives the technology too much credit and us too little. The more useful question is what it is being used for, and how. Using AI to remove friction, to get past a blank page or reorganise notes, is a different act from handing over the thinking. For me, its real value has been as a listener that pushes back. Explaining a half-formed idea until it is understood forces me to put it in order, and the thought in my head is better for it. The flattening remains, but it is easier to resist when AI is one voice among many.

Through working with AI, I have found a way to articulate ideas that had sat half-formed for years. The technology wasn’t the difference; how I used it was. The pushback was the mechanism, but the reorganising and challenging happened in my own head. What I handed over and what I kept, where I accepted suggestions and where I kept ownership of the final edit, were my decisions. That judgement can be practised, taught and shared, and it is how we keep hold of our own voice.

References

Davis, J.L. (2020) How artifacts afford: the power and politics of everyday things. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.

Vallor, S. (2024) The AI mirror: how to reclaim our humanity in an age of machine thinking. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Author

Richard Ward, DL Producer, CCW, UAL

Email: richard.ward@arts.ac.uk

A link to Part 2 in The Mediated Self series will be added here when the post is available.


Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *